Here's what I made, and you can print out the tag below to do the same.
Pick up a couple of fun rolls of washi tape from the store (or your stash) and slide it in a little bag along with a gift card (if you want...we went with Sonic)
Print out the tags (there are 3 on each page) and glue it down on a piece of colored cardstock. You can also download the svg for the scalloped base I used and cut it with an electronic cutter. Decorate with a small strip of tape, punch a hole in the corner and tie it onto the bag. I had my kids each write a little not to their teacher on the back too.
All set! And now I have one less thing to worry about when I'm gone.
You could also use this same tag with any of these items (some which would work great for male teachers too!)
What did I forget that would work here?
Printable Teacher Tag
Scalloped Frame SVG