I made these specifically for my kid-friendly Halloween party, but I'll be able to use them for anything. And they're cheap enough that you could make a couple sets for different color schemes.
Dollar Store items: Pizza pan, pie plate, candlestick
I painted the candlestick with glass paint first before gluing it all together with E6000. Mark the centers with a permanent marker so the candlestick goes right in the middle.
Dollar Store items: Plastic bowls, candlesticks
These candlesticks were painted with black spray paint then glued to the bottom of the bowls.
What's your favorite party item to pick up from dollar stores?